Wednesday, December 18, 2013

My Year of Books: Best Cover Designs of 2013


As a matter of fact, yes, I do judge a book by its cover—at least, initially.  A good cover has the ability to make or break a book's marketplace success—even in the ever-increasing digital world where cover designs are most frequently seen as small as thumbnails at on-line retailers.  This past year saw some outstanding covers which caught my eye and made me stop to take a closer look.  Here, in no particular order, are my favorite book covers of 2013 (I've listed the designer's name whenever possible).

I Want to Show You More by Jamie Quatro
Design by Rachel Perry Welty
Aluminum foil was invented in 1910, but it wasn't until this year that it found its true calling: a spot-on perfect design element on the cover of Jamie Quatro's debut short story collection.  There's nothing boring about Quatro's fiction—so don't judge the contents by the cover's mono-chrome of grey and silver.  The fabulous art is by Rachel Perry Welty; you can see more of her work here.  With everything encased in foil—including all but the head and arms of the blonde-haired, droop-winged angel—it's like the book is ready to be broiled in the oven.  I also think it was a smart design decision to use a cursive "font" for the words, making it seem like the ribbon of Reynolds Wrap is endless (in some of Welty's other work, she does indeed use one sheet of foil).


The Good House by Ann Leary
Everything on this cover works for me: the mustard-yellow house buried up to its roofline in snow, the bold black serif font, that solitary red cardinal perched on the eaves.  The novel is about an alcoholic Realtor, just out of rehab, who finds herself embroiled in small-town gossip and eventually up to her neck in scandal.  The cover nicely hints at that domesticity and danger.


You Are One of Them by Elliott Holt
Design by Janet Hansen
The cover of Elliott Holt's debut novel cleverly obscures half the face of a person standing at a train window with a black cloud of what could be spray paint, an ink blot, a smear of violent graffiti. Designer Janet Hansen takes advantage of that dark blot of negative space by filling it with the title and author's name. The partial black mask is a nice play on the title's implied theme of identity, assimilation, and homogeneity.


The Curiosity by Stephen P. Kiernan
Design by Mary Schuck
Nothing says "Buy Me!" better than the sight of empty clothes on a book cover.  And when they're found in the shape of a man sprawled across a snowbank?  I say, "Bingo!"  Kiernan's curious novel is about what happens when a man frozen in ice for nearly a century is reanimated by a team of scientists.  In addition to suffering loss of identity, apparently he gets a new wardrobe.


Tampa by Alissa Nutting
Design by John Gray
Yes, yes, the original hardcover version of Alissa Nutting's novel was irresistible to touch—a black-velvet material which could also double as a lint brush if you got bored with the book (which is hard to imagine)—but I want to talk about the cover for the paperback which will be released by Faber and Faber in March 2014.  We live in an era of provocative book covers (see the latest version of Erica Jong's Fear of Flyinghere's the whole, um, spread—or any recent version of Lolita, for instance), but Tampa's might be one of the provocativiest.  Here's all you need to know about the book: junior high school teacher Celeste Price has an insatiable hunger for sex....and not just any kind of sex, but wild, horny humping with one of her students.  Now take a second look at that closeup of a buttonhole on a pink shirt.  Are you blushing yet?


Mozart by Paul Johnson
Design by Jason Ramirez
Paul Johnson's biography is as diminutive as the composer himself (164 pages and "not much over five foot," respectively), but the book's cover design packs all the wallop of a crescendoing aria, cleverly using Barbara Krafft's portrait of Amadeus to make the book leap off the shelf.  I love how the famous painting is layered with a scarlet-red curtain and five-lined music staffs.  The effect is simultaneously subtle and in-your-face beautiful. I would probably read Johnson's biography anyway, but the fire-engine, Canadian-Mountie-jacket, supermodel-lipstick red of the jacket design insists I do so sooner rather than later.  Fortissimo!


edited by Sarah Weinman
Design by Lynn Buckley
This crime fiction anthology is a salute to "the real femmes fatales of the domestic suspense genre," pioneering writers like Patricia Highsmith, Shirley Jackson and Dorothy B. Hughes.  The cover design, by the same token, is a tribute to the popular pulp magazine covers of that bygone era. A Barbara Stanwyckian femme is caught in the beam of a flashlight, startled eyes popping out of her head, hand up, fingers curled, claws out. This is a cover that will reach out and grab bookstore browsers and lead them to this most worthy collection of short fiction.


The Resurrectionist by E. B. Hudspeth
One glance at the book's plot synopsis and you know this creepy skeleton is the perfect gateway to the novel: "Philadelphia, the late 1870s.  A city of gas lamps, cobblestone streets, and horse-drawn carriages—and home to the controversial surgeon Dr. Spencer Black.  The son of a grave robber, young Dr. Black studies at Philadelphia’s esteemed Academy of Medicine, where he develops an unconventional hypothesis: What if the world’s most celebrated mythological beasts—mermaids, minotaurs, and satyrs—were in fact the evolutionary ancestors of humankind?"


The Deep Whatsis by Peter Mattei
Design by John Gall
You'd be forgiven if you thought the title of this novel was "A Novel."  Mattei's satire about corporate hypocrisy gets an appropriately slutty design which boldly subverts our expectations, starting with the size-reduction of the already quirky title.  When you reduce this cover to a thumbnail on the Internets, the white bleed at the edges makes its borders disappear and that huge "A Novel" just floats there in midscreen suspension, forcing you to exclaim, "Hey, whatsis?"


Wild Ones by Jon Mooallem
The subtitle of Mooallem's book about wildlife conservation is "A Sometimes Dismaying, Weirdly Reassuring Story About Looking at People Looking at Animals in America" (this gets my vote for Subtitle of the Year, by the way).  Nothing says "conservation" quite like a spotlit polar bear trapped in a glass case.  The cover is simultaneously simple, complex, beautiful, and horrible in its meaning.


The Accursed by Joyce Carol Oates
Design by Allison Saltzman
Using a detail from Giovanni Boldini's Profile of a Young Woman, designer Allison Saltzman focuses our attention on the exposed, alabaster-white neck—appropriate, given the fact that Oates' big novel about turn-of-the-century Princeton includes vampires in its cast of characters (along with Woodrow Wilson, Jack London and Mark Twain).  One of the other things I love about this cover is how Saltzman echoes the bunch of lavender in the title's font color, with the blood-red of the author's name coming between them.  For such a beautiful art design, there's a lot of underlying tension at work here.


Manson by Jeff Guinn
You were expecting the beard and the crazy-eyes, weren't you?  No, for this biography, we get a curious, atypical photo of the titular monster.  The unsettling school photo, along with the yellow crime scene tape, works well to dash our image of Manson.


Shouting Won't Help by Katherine Bouton
Design by Jenny Carrow
This book about hearing loss gets a nicely metaphorical treatment for its cover.  Bouton, an editor at the New York Times, describes how she slowly went deaf—she was, as she puts it, “the kind of person who might have used an ear trumpet in the nineteenth century.” As the title and cover design imply, to the hearing impaired, our efforts to understand and help are no better than if we were screaming underwater. One other thing—and maybe I'm reaching here—but it looks like the upper half of the submerged woman's head is an island—further indicative of Bouton's isolation.


Johnny Cash by Robert Hilburn
Design by Julianna Lee
The cigaretted face dominates the cover, as well it should since the Man was almost too large for his own life.


Design by Adam Johnson
I'm a sucker for artistic photos of people suspended in mid-water (see also: Tethered by Amy MacKinnon) and this one used for Neil Gaiman's beautiful adult fairy tale completely captivated me from the start.  There is such sublime perfection in this cover design, I hardly know where to begin:  The icy chill of the blue?  The way the title is set off by the blurred oval?  The stark white of the font?  That cloudy net of bubbles coming from the girl's mouth?  As good as Gaiman's prose may have been (and it was very good), I couldn't stop closing the book and gazing with lovesick sighs at this cover.


Tinderbox by Lisa Gornick
Design by Rodrigo Corral
Okay, admit it—you want to know what a toy triceratops is doing playing with matches, don't you?  So do I.  It's enough to get us inside this novel about what Daniel Menaker calls "the story of a family undergoing seismic changes brought on by a stranger who unwittingly forces her hosts to face themselves."  That calm pink border belies the incendiary tension within these pages.


Fosse by Sam Wasson
Design by Martha Kennedy
Can't you just hear Bob Fosse exclaiming, "It's showtime, folks!"?  The legendary choreographer, director and actor deservedly gets the spotlight in Wasson's biography.  The cover also seems to catch Fosse in the spotlight, beckoning to an unlit stage.  The only thing that would have made this cover any better is if the F-O-S-S-E were made of blinking lights.

~

My Year of Books is the annual backward glance of my literary life.  All this week, I'll be posting lists of the best things I read in 2013.  Be sure to visit the rest of the series (links posted as they're published):

Monday:  By the Numbers
Tuesday:  Best First Lines
Wednesday:  Best Cover Designs
Thursday:  Best of the Backlist
Friday:  Best Fiction of 2013
Saturday:  Publisher of the Year


Tuesday, December 17, 2013

Trailer Tuesday: Fobbit


Welcome to Trailer Tuesday, a showcase of new book trailers and, in a few cases, previews of book-related movies.



For nearly two years, I've told you about promotional trailers for other authors' books....and now it's time for me to cue the spotlight, step to the center of the stage, clear my throat for the microphone, and announce: "Ladies and gentlemen.... Fobbit, the trailer!"  Yes, that's right, I finally got my act together and made a book trailer for my novel which debuted over a year ago.  More accurately, I hired the services of the wonderful team of Liz and Rob at The Montana Movie Factory, a great production company right here in Butte, Montana.  I gave Rob just a few sketchy ideas and let him take it from there.  I'm very pleased with the end result (Rob even managed to sneak in a Monty Python homage at the very end).  I hope you'll like what we came up with.  Consider it a Christmas gift to all the Fobbit fans out there.


My Year of Books: Best First Lines of 2013


If, as Ursula K. LeGuin has said, "First sentences are doors to worlds," then I turned a lot of great doorknobs this year.  My favorite lines are those which pack a lot of information and pack a hefty linguistic punch, but don't send me packing.  The best first sentences keep me in the book, demand I read the next sentence and the next one after that, and so on until--five hours later, I look up from the page and realize the house is burning down around my ears.

Here, in no particular order, are my favorite opening lines from books published in 2013 (or ones which I first encountered this past year):


The hookers were slap-fighting a Hare Krishna up at the intersection when the bullet came through the windshield.


The camp at Auschwitz took one year of my life, and of my own free will I gave it another four.
The Thief of Auschwitz by Jon Clinch


The ward was never the same after that February afternoon when Zelda Fitzgerald stumbled into the psychiatric clinic with a stack of papers clutched to her chest, eyes darting this way and that, at once pushing from and pulling toward her husband like a spinning magnet.
Call Me Zelda by Erika Robuck


I was on my second bag of Doritos and my lips were stained emergency orange when my best friend, Phillip, said he knew a bar in Hallelujah Junction that didn’t card, and maybe we should go there.


When I was twelve years old I was best friends with a baby.
Saguaro by Carson Mell


Tonight I went from my wife's bed to the open window and pissed down blood on Royal Street.
The Blood of Heaven by Kent Wascom


There is very little peace for a man with a body buried in his backyard.
Three Graves Full by Jamie Mason


The night before my father would beg me to kill him, I sat alone in a hotel room across the street from his hospital, rereading old newspaper articles about my mother's suicide.
The Cost of Living by Rob Roberge


The intern from the edit house is so drunk she is trying to take her skin off.
The Deep Whatsis by Peter Mattei


Four days before the bomb that is supposed to obliterate Bombay and kill us all, I stand in the ruins of Crawford Market, haggling with the lone remaining fruit seller over the price of the pomegranate in my hand.
The City of Devi by Manil Suri


When Hitler came to power I was in the bath.
All That I Am by Anna Funder


Nurse Thornton dropped into the long-term-care ward a little before eight with a hot bag of blood for Charlie Manx.
NOS4A2 by Joe Hill


On the morning after the Feds burned down her house and took her father, Havaa woke from dreams of sea anemones.


I am a woman with no fingerprints.


A little over thirty years ago, on a June day just before sunset--alone on a mountain in Marin County, California--a man came toward me with a length of piano wire stretched between his hands, and the intention of ending my days.
After Her by Joyce Maynard


I fell in love with William Ashe at gunpoint, in a Circle K.
Someone Else's Love Story by Joshilyn Jackson


On an April day in 1970, when most of his fellow architecture students were taking their spring break, Frank Joyner drew a Gillette razor blade across his left wrist with one express purpose in mind: he wanted to see if, when the blood appeared, he was willing to let it flow, or if, in fact, he wanted to live.
Fractures by Lamar Herrin

~

My Year of Books is the annual backward glance of my literary life.  All this week, I'll be posting lists of the best things I read in 2013.  Be sure to visit the rest of the series (links posted as they're published):

Monday:  By the Numbers
Tuesday:  Best First Lines
Wednesday:  Best Cover Designs
Thursday:  Best of the Backlist
Friday:  Best Fiction of 2013
Saturday:  Publisher of the Year


Monday, December 16, 2013

My Year of Books: By the Numbers


"Well, hello!  Come in, come in.  Stamp the snow off your boots and step inside.  Cold out there today, isn't it?....I suppose you're here to see the library, aren't you?....Here, let me take your coat.  I'll just toss it over here for now.  You don't mind if the cats use it as a temporary bed, do you?....Would you like a drink?  I've got some chilled wine--or maybe you'd rather have three fingers of whiskey in a tumbler?....What's that?  A gin and tonic?  Sure, I can whip one of those up for you....Follow me to the basement--that's where all the books are anyway....Watch your step coming down here--the cats like to play this little game they call Trip the Human--they score extra points if they're able to do a perfect figure eight around your feet....Anyway, here we are: the BOOKS.  Why don't you take a look around while I pour the gin and tonics?....What's that you say?  Have I read all of them?  Of course not!  Are you frickin' insane?  That's the stupidest question I've heard in a long time."

Okay, I don't actually say that last line to guests who visit the library in my basement, but believe me, I'm asked that question--"Have you read all of these?"--nearly every time someone comes down and stops, wide-eyed and slack-jawed, when they see the bookshelves which line all four walls of the main room, spill over into the furnace area and continue around the perimeter of what used to be my office.  They are dazzled by the infinite platoons of book spines and I suppose those are the only half-sensible words they can croak out.  My library is indeed a shining example of American greed, overconsumption and obsessive-compulsive collecting.  It is simultaneously pretty and not-pretty.  According to my Library Thing account, I currently own 8,253 books (which doesn't include several hundred I haven't yet catalogued in LT).  I could cut off my book intake right now, live seven more lifetimes, and still not have enough time to read everything in my collection.

But every year, I try my damnedest to make a sizable dent.

In 2013, I made more than a dent--I made a small crater.  Tallying up the book log statistics, I came up with--drumroll, please--81 books read in the past twelve months.  That pales in comparison to the high school girl who, after a Fobbit presentation I gave at her school in May, came up to me and boasted she read 500 books in the past year.  I'm happy for her, but I could never get up to that level of reading consumption.  Unless, maybe, I was laid up in bed all year with consumption.

Nonetheless, I'm pretty proud of the 81 titles I read this year.  Going deeper into the stats, I see that equals 18,744 pages, for an average of 231 pages per book.  Compared to last year's figures--56 books and 14,524 pages--that's like shifting into high gear and pressing the accelerator to the floor.

The page counts ranged from 32 for a children's book about Billie Holiday (Mister and Lady Day by Amy Novesky) to the 544 spine-tingling pages of Benjamin Percy's epic werewolf saga Red Moon.  Well, if we're going to be precise, I guess The Big Book of Christmas Mysteries takes the prize for Most Pages (650).  Even though I haven't finished Otto Penzler's anthology of Yuletide murder and mayhem, I'm going to add it to this year's count because even if I don't finish it by the time I'm sipping New Year's Eve champagne, the vast bulk of it will have been read in 2013.  So it counts.  My blog, my rules, my math.

There are still a couple of unfinished books on the bedside table: the annotated Lolita by Vladimir Nabokov and The Complete Short Novels of Anton Chekhov, for instance.  Those will just have to go on next year's tally.

There's also a long list of books I wanted to get to this year but didn't--the old Eyes Bigger Than the Stomach Rule.  That roster includes Victoria Wilson's biography of Barbara Stanwyck, Doctor Sleep by Stephen King, The Goldfinch by Donna Tartt (hell, ALL of Tart's books, for that matter, since she's been a permanent residence of my TBR mountain), The People of Forever Are Not Afraid by Shani Boianjiu, The Luminaries by Eleanor Catton, Schroder by Amity Gaige, and--well, you get the idea.  There are a lot of books still waiting for my attention.

Lest you think I never took my nose out of a book this year, you should also know that I hold down a regular, 40-hour-per-week Day Job (apart from writing novels and feeding/ watering this blog).  Not only that, but my wife and I opened up a vintage mercantile here in Butte, Montana this year, I continued to jet from city to city on an extended book tour for Fobbit, and we undertook a couple of major home renovation projects.  I was--and still remain--a busy guy who is only able to embroider the edges of his life with a couple hours of reading each day (if I'm very lucky).  Still, there are few things in life more pleasurable than coming home after work and, in the short span of time before I start to cook dinner, settling in with a good book and tumbler of whiskey--all while casting an eye to the other 8,252 books on the shelves in the basement library, reassuring them, "I'll get to you soon."

~

My Year of Books is the annual backward glance of my literary life.  All this week, I'll be posting lists of the best things I read in 2013.  Be sure to visit the rest of the series (links posted as they're published):

Monday:  By the Numbers
Tuesday:  Best First Lines
Wednesday:  Best Cover Designs
Thursday:  Best of the Backlist
Friday:  Best Fiction of 2013
Saturday:  Publisher of the Year


My First Time: Anne Clinard Barnhill


My First Time is a regular feature in which writers talk about virgin experiences in their writing and publishing careers, ranging from their first rejection to the moment of holding their first published book in their hands. Today’s guest is Anne Clinard Barnhill, author of At the Mercy of the Queen: a Novel of Anne Boleyn. Barnhill has been writing professionally for almost twenty-five years, publishing articles and short stories in various magazines and anthologies. Her new novel, Queen Elizabeth’s Daughter, will be released by St. Martin’s Press in March 2014. The author of three other books and a poetry chapbook, she enjoys writing in a variety of genres. She also loves to tickle the ivories, play bridge and most especially, assume her role as the superhero Bottom Woman, a game she plays with her 6-year-old grandson. Visit her website, and track her down on Twitter and Facebook.


My First Agent

Thus far, in my writing career, I’ve had two agents. My current agent has been with me since late 2009. But the first one—ah, I’ll never forget the thrill of that phone call.

I was in the hospital, hooked up to a morphine drip, after having suffered an attack of pancreatitis caused by gall stones. To say I was a bit woozy is an understatement. My husband had come to visit and had told me this woman had called our home. He’d given her the hospital number and had returned to the hospital himself before she called.

When the phone rang, he answered, winking at me as he handed me the receiver.

“I love your book!” she said.

“Thhahhhk yooou,” I said.

“I’d really love to represent you—will you sign with me?” she said.

“Yes, yes I will mahrryy yooou,” I said, thinking I was the most clever writer ever for that remark.

She didn’t respond to my comment, but I'll never forget her last words to me: “I’m going to make you famous!”

Luckily, my health issues resolved quickly. She’d sent me the contract overnight and I’d signed, happy as a puppy. I’d worked long and hard to find an agent and she was well-established and reputable. I expected to hear from her soon.

This was in April.

By August, I had not heard a word. I should have known this did not bode well. But I was an innocent in the ways of the publishing world and ever optimistic.

Finally, in desperation, I called her. She told me she was having a hard time selling the book, but not to worry—she was still waiting for a few responses.

December rolled around, not a word yet from the agent. About a week before Christmas, I watched as the UPS truck backed down our long driveway.

Oh goody! I thought. Someone is sending me a Christmas present!

I opened the box eagerly. On top, were fifteen rejection letters in all their glory. And, number 16 was a letter from my agent, saying she was dropping me. She hadn’t sold the book and she didn’t like the second novel, so…

Merry damn Christmas.

I crawled to the kitchen and curled up in a tight little ball. I cried, oh, maybe three hours. It was a devastating blow, to say the least. And then, I did something very silly. I put my manuscript away. I thought surely it must be no good.

WRONG!—At least, wrong thinking. What I should have thought was, well, I got one agent, I can send this bad boy off and surely get another. Instead, I put the book away and I have not touched it since. Its moment had passed and I no longer had interest in it.

But I learned something important. When you get a nibble, you keep fishing. If one slips off the hook, you bait it again and recast. You don’t quit. You don’t allow rejection to stop you. You keep on keeping on.

Not a bad Christmas gift, when you think about it.


Sunday, December 15, 2013

Sunday Sentence: The Big Book of Christmas Mysteries edited by Otto Penzler


Simply put, the best sentence(s) I've read this past week, presented out of context and without commentary.  (In the holiday spirit of generosity, I'm breaking the rules and giving you three different sentences this week--all found in The Big Book of Christmas Mysteries, edited by Otto Penzler.  You're welcome.)


"My name is Sherlock Holmes.  It is my business to know what other people don't know."

From "The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle" by Arthur Conan Doyle


Miss Ypson had not always been dead; au contraire.  She had lived for seventy-eight years, for most of them breathing hard.
From "The Adventure of the Dauphin's Doll" by Ellery Queen


They walked until it was entirely Christmas Eve, and they were entirely alone in the snow that began to fall again, making tiny, perfect stars of lace that lingered in her dark hair.
From "Dead on Christmas Street" by John D. MacDonald



Saturday, December 14, 2013

Front Porch Books: December 2013 edition


Front Porch Books is a monthly tally of booksmainly advance review copies (aka "uncorrected proofs" and "galleys")I've received from publishers, but also sprinkled with packages from Book Mooch, Amazon and other sources.  Because my dear friends, Mr. FedEx and Mrs. UPS, leave them with a doorbell-and-dash method of delivery, I call them my Front Porch Books.  In this digital age, ARCs are also beamed to the doorstep of my Kindle via NetGalley and Edelweiss.  Note: most of these books won't be released for another 2-6 months; I'm just here to pique your interest and stock your wish lists. Cover art and opening lines may change before the book is finally released.


Stop Here by Beverly Gologorsky (Seven Stories Press):  I'll begin this snapshot of Gologorsky's second novel with a bit of Blurbworthiness from Elizabeth Strout (author of Olive Kitteridge): "Unflinching, piercing, Gologorsky looks straight into the face of class in this country, capturing the reverberations across generations of who really fights our wars, who really serves our coffee, who really gets up in the dark to wipe the diners' counter clean. This book is filled with an array of characters whose bravery is unsung, women who persevere with a dignity unseen by many, until Gologorsky pulls the curtain back and allows us in.” Those women are Ava, Mila, and Rosalyn who all work at Murray's Diner in Long Island.  As the Jacket Copy tells us: "They are friends and coworkers struggling to hold together their disordered lives. While Ava privately grieves the loss of her husband in the first Iraq War, Mila struggles to dissuade her seventeen-year-old daughter from enlisting in the second. Rosalyn works as an escort by night until love and illness conspire to disrupt the tenuous balance she'd found and the past she'd kept at a safe distance. The promise of a new relationship with a coworker soon begins to restore Ava's faith in her own ability to feel, and Mila learns through wrenching loss that children must learn from their own mistakes. But ultimately it is love—for one another and for their wayward families—that sustains them through the pain and uncertainty of a world with no easy answers." Gologorsky's first novel, The Things We Do To Make It Home, was published by Random House in 1999. Though once-a-decade writers like Jeffrey Eugenides and Donna Tartt get all the media ink, there's no doubt the term "long-awaited" can be applied to Gologorsky as well. Judging by the Opening Lines, the wait seems to have been worth it. The novel opens with a party at Murray's house:
      There’s no way to ignore the warmongering on Fox News, though Ava is trying. The screen takes up half the wall. Hours ago, it seems, she searched for the remote to lower the volume, but no luck. She went so far as to ask Murray to turn it off, but instead he began jabbering about our brave boys, keeping the country safe, on and on like he knew something no one else did. That sent her mind reeling back to the evening her son pulled her onto the couch to watch the invasion of Iraq. Shock and Awe, he said, repeating what he’d heard the newscasters call it. Then, too, she wanted to close her eyes. She told him the sights were frightening, nothing to celebrate, but it didn’t dampen Bobby’s childish excitement. That scared her, too. No one seems bothered by the TV. The party is in this room where the food table and bar are set up, where wraparound windows allow only blueberry darkness, where vaulted ceilings create echoes as people talk and gesture and take up space. If she could find a corner to be alone—to hide, actually—it would help, but no luck there either. She avoids parties, fears the expectations, the false gaiety, and worse, strangers’ idle curiosity.
      Maybe another glass of wine, but her head feels spacey, her fingers tingle, and when she tries to breathe deep her body tenses. It’s been a while since anxiety dogged her, though it happened a lot after her husband was killed. Damn TV. It’s boring through her senses.
I'm looking forward to reading the rest of Stop Here—which, by all appearances, deserves to be heard above all that warmongering chatter on Fox News.


Death on Blackheath by Anne Perry (Ballantine Books):  I'm a late-comer to the Anne Perry party and, in fact, have only read a couple of her Christmas mysteries.  But thanks to the Opening Lines of this new Charlotte and Thomas Pitt novel, I might just have to start exploring the Victorian world of these sleuths:
      Pitt stood shivering on the steps leading up from the areaway to the pavement and looked down at the clumps of blood and hair at his feet. There was blood on the shards of glass as well, and some of it had already congealed. Splinters lay on the steps below and above. The January wind whined across the open stretch towards the gravel pits in the distance.
      "And the maid is missing?" Pitt asked quietly.
      "Yes, and sorry, sir," the police sergeant said unhappily. His young face was set hard in the grey early morning light. "Thought that seeing whose house it was, like, we should call you straight away."
      "You did the right thing," Pitt assured him.
Here's the Jacket Copy to tell us more about the gore on those steps:
As commander of the powerful Special Branch, Thomas Pitt has the job of keeping Britain safe from spies and traitors. So there’s no obvious reason why he is suddenly ordered to investigate two minor incidents: the blood, hair, and shards of glass discovered outside the home of naval weapons expert Dudley Kynaston, and the simultaneous disappearance of Mrs. Kynaston’s beautiful lady’s maid. But weeks later, when the mutilated body of an unidentified young woman is found near Kynaston’s home, Pitt realizes that this is no ordinary police investigation. Far from it. Is Kynaston—one of Britain’s most valuable scientists—leading a double life? Is Pitt saddled with a conspiracy so devilishly clever that it will ruin him? A baffled Pitt has never needed his friends more desperately, including his indomitable wife, Charlotte; his canny old colleague Victor Narraway; and his personal drawing-room spy, Lady Vespasia Cumming-Gould. But even these allies may not be able to save Pitt—or Britain.

Dakota by Gwen Florio (The Permanent Press):  Moving from Victorian-era England to the present-day oil fields of North Dakota, we come to Gwen Florio's follow-up to her debut mystery, Montana (which was just released last month).  Once again, Florio's amateur detective Lola Wicks is on the case—this time involving a dead girl in a snowbank.  Here's the Jacket Copy to spill the plot points:
Former foreign correspondent Lola Wicks is getting a little bored in Magpie, Montana, where she landed at a small local newspaper after being downsized from her job in Kabul. Then Judith Calf Looking, a local Blackfeet girl missing for several months, turns up dead in a snowbank with a mysterious brand on her forearm. The sheriffwhose romantic relationship with Lola provides Magpie with its most delicious gossip in yearsthinks Judith probably froze to death while hitch-hiking back to the reservation from wherever she’d been. But Lola hears rumors that Judith had been working as an exotic dancer in the North Dakota oil fields, and further discovers that several Blackfeet girls, all known drug users, have gone missing over the past year. She heads out to the oil patch to check things out, only to find herself in a place where men outnumber women a hundred to one, the law looks the other way, and lifeespecially her ownis cheap. Dakota shows the frightening underside of a boom-and-bust economy; of the effect on a small town when big-city money washes in, accompanied by hordes of men far from their families; of what happens when the old rules no longer apply, but the new ones are yet to be determined.
With the current boom-or-bust growth on the Bakken oil fields in Montana and the Dakotas, Florio's new mystery couldn't be more timely.


Byrd by Kim Church (Dzanc Books):  Kim Church's debut novel opens with a mother writing a tell-all letter to a son she never knew—one she gave up for adoption soon after his birth years ago.
      Dear Byrd,
      This is how I told your father.
      We climbed up on his roof. We could see the ocean, wrinkles of light in the distance. I was wearing a billowy cotton skirt. I wanted to look soft, unthreatening, unselfconsciously pretty. I wanted your father to love me. My legs were pale, not used to sun in winter. I had painted my toenails lavender. I wanted him to be a little sorry he hadn't loved me all along.
      The roof of his apartment was flat, asphalt. All grit and sparkle.
      He was glad to see me, he said. He didn't ask why I'd come back.
      He unfolded an orange blanket from his sofa bed and we laid out our picnic: smoothies, crinkle-cut fries from his favorite stand on the beach, canned peaches from his kitchen, and barbecue I'd brought from home, packed on dry ice. So much food. I had to make myself eat. I chewed slowly, counting each bite, the way you're supposed to, though I couldn't remember how high to count.
      A warm breeze ruffled my skirt.
      Your father offered to spike my smoothie, but I covered my cup with my hand.
      I wish I could tell you we were young, inexperienced, not yet grownups or ready to be. That's the story you're expecting, isn't it?
      We were thirty-two. We'd grown up together. Everything about the afternoon
our picnic, the roof, the sun, the salty air, your father's pilled orange blanket, him sitting close and warm beside mehad been coming all our lives.
As you can see, there's some fine writing in those Opening Lines, a sparkle-promise of good things to come in the rest of the novel.  I'm not even off the first page and I'm already invested in the lives of these characters.  That's the power of tight, controlled writing—so, kudos to Ms. Church!  Here's the Jacket Copy to tell us more about Byrd and his parents:
Addie Lockwood believes in books. Roland Rhodes believes in blues guitar. Coming of age in the small-town South of the 1970s, they form an unlikely friendship that makes each of them feel, if only for a little while, extraordinary. They meet again in their disillusioned thirties, this time in California, where Roland’s music career has landed him. Venice Beach is exotic, a world away from North Carolina and Addie’s cloistered life as a bookstore clerk. But when their whirlwind reunion leaves Addie pregnant, reality sets in. Conflicted, unready to be a mother, she gives birth and surrenders her baby for adoption without telling Roland, little imagining how the secret will shape their lives. Told through sharply-drawn vignettes and Addie's letters to her son, Byrd is an unforgettable story about making and living with the most difficult, intimate, and far-reaching of choices.
Blurbworthiness: "This protagonist is so appealing, with her unflinching moral candor, her mistakes based on generous instincts. The prose is lilting, joyous. This novel—about young lives that start out full of promise, falter, then recover—is a hard luck story that will make you feel good."  (Debra Monroe, author of On the Outskirts of Normal)


Afghan Post by Adrian Bonenberger (The Head & The Hand Press):  Composed entirely of letters, journal entries and the occasional glossary of military terms, Adrian Bonenberger's Afghan Post is not your typical war memoir (which is funny, given the original title he was contemplating for this book: Just Another War Memoir).  Though I've only had enough time to dip briefly into its pages and take a few sips here and there, Afghan Post looks like it will be a rewarding journey through the physical mechanics of combat and the spiritual toll it takes on an individual.  By building his story through correspondence, Bronenberger invests Afghan Post with the immediacy of every situation in which he finds himself, written in the white-hot emotion of the moment.  Here's the Jacket Copy to give us a little more background on the book:
Afghan Post begins in 2001 with the attack on the World Trade Center and follows Adrian’s journey from Yale English major to U.S. Army captain in letters and journal entries. Over the course of the memoir, under the strain of war, Adrian’s identity splits and splits again as he maintains different correspondences with friends and family, fellow veterans, and himself. The tectonic shifts in relationships, mental states, and levels of physical danger cause Adrian to reevaluate his rejection of the many paths that were available to him post-graduation in favor of volunteering for military service. He left the Army as a decorated captain in 2012 after two tours.
Blurbworthiness: "This is one of the best memoirs to emerge from our recent wars. It is painfully honest as we see the author grow from being a narcissistic Yalie weenie who judges the 'aesthetics' of paratrooping to an Airborne captain who revels in commanding an infantry company in combat—and then is crushed by it. One way to thank vets for their service is to read this book." (Thomas E. Ricks, author of The Generals)


Flushboy by Stephen Graham Jones (Dzanc Books):  If hygienic matters of the water closet are not your thing, you might want to move on.  But if, on the other hand, you don't mind descriptions of the activity in which all of us—to a person—engage on a daily (sometimes thrice-daily) basis, then Stephen Graham Jones' newest novel will have you flushed with pleasure.  In fact, urine for a real treat here.  Hey, don't blame me for the puns.  Wordplay abounds in Flushboy, starting with headings Jones gives the novel's sections: "The Urinal Cake Blues," "The Great American Splashdown," "Leaktakers and Heartbreakers," and "The Gospel of P."  Jones is the author of ten novels, three short story collections, and one novella--and I'm guessing he's not exactly a household name where you live.  By all accounts, he's one of America's most overlooked contemporary novelists (including, I'll admit, by me).  I'm not sure if Flushboy will be his breakout book, but I'm definitely willing to give it a go, based on the zippy energy of its Opening Lines:
      So there's video footage of me not washing my hands in the bathroom at work. My dad says it's the kind of the thing that can tank his whole business. That he has to be extra careful. Don't I understand?
      Usually when he's spewing all this, I just stand there.
      Last week I was his show-and-tell for Sunday school class. We wore matching ties, and I was under strict orders not to smile or look sly. Some of those people were his customers, after all.
      I don't know.
      Anyway, bam, yeah, the camera caught me: I ran the water but didn't wash my hands. Even pulled down a paper towel or two because that's the kind of thing you can hear through a metal door.
      So, really, it's two crimes: bad hygiene and wasting paper towels.
The Jacket Copy only offers a small hint of the plot—but it's enough for me: "Over the course of one shift working the window of his father's drive-through urinal, our sixteen-year-old Flushboy will have to not only juggle gallons of warm pee and deal with the worst flood ever (it's not water), but he'll also have to fend off the urine mafia, solve the citywide mystery of Chickenstein, and win his girlfriend back."  Wait—did he just say drive-through urinal?  Hmmm....I'd better sit down for this.


The Mist in the Mirror by Susan Hill (Vintage):  I've only read one of Susan Hill's many Gothic horror novels—The Man in the Picture—but I was so thoroughly creeped out that as soon as I finished it, I wanted more.  So along comes The Mist in the Mirror, a classic ghost story which appears to be just the thing to really put the chill in this winter weather we're having out here in Montana.  The Jacket Copy even helps fray the nerves:
For the last twenty years Sir James Monmouth has journeyed all over the globe in the footsteps of his hero, the great pioneering traveler Conrad Vane. In an effort to learn more about Vane’s early life—and his own—Sir James sets off for the remote Kittiscar Hall on a cold and rainy winter night. But he soon begins to feel as though something is warning him away at every turn; there are the intense feelings of being watched and the strange apparitions of a sad little boy. And as he learns more about his hero’s past, he discovers that they are only the beginning, for Kittiscar Hall is hiding terrible secret that will bind their lives together in ways he could never have imagined.
Remote English manors, boy ghosts, terrible secrets?  Yep, I'm already on my way.  I look no further than the Opening Lines to help set the mood:
      London, and the library of my Club, toward the end of an afternoon in late November, that bleak, dispiriting time of year when the golden Indian summer days that lingered on through October seem long gone, and it is yet too early to feel the approaching cheer of Christmas.
      Outside in the streets the air was raw and a light mizzle greased the pavements, and had chilled my face and damped the sleeves of my coat.
Blurbworthiness: "Thanks to Hill’s deceptively simple plots and straightforward prose, you won’t even notice the noose she’s slipping around your throat."  (The Seattle Times)


2 a.m. at The Cat's Pajamas by Marie-Helene Bertino (Crown):  This debut novel by Marie-Helene Bertino doesn't come out until next August, but I'm telling you about it now as a courtesy so you can hurry up and whittle down your To-Be-Read pile, clearing your plate for what looks like a great book to get you in the mood for next Christmas.  Take a gander at the Jacket Copy:
Madeline Altimari is a smart-mouthed, precocious nine-year-old and an aspiring jazz singer. As she mourns the recent death of her mother, she doesn't realize that on Christmas Eve Eve she is about to have the most extraordinary dayand nightof her life. After bravely facing down mean-spirited classmates and rejection at school, Madeline doggedly searches for Philadelphia's legendary jazz club The Cat's Pajamas, where she's determined to make her on-stage debut. On the same day, her fifth-grade teacher Sarina Greene, who's just moved back to Philly after a divorce, is nervously looking forward to a dinner party that will reunite her with an old high school crush, afraid to hope that sparks might fly again. And across town at The Cat's Pajamas, club owner Lorca discovers that his beloved haunt may have to close forever, unless someone can find a way to quickly raise the $30,000 that would save it. As these three lost souls search for love, music and hope on the snow-covered streets of Philadelphia, together they will discover life's endless possibilities over the course of one magical night.
I'm already entranced by the Opening Lines:
Silent flurries fall in the city. Actors walking home from a cast party on Broad Street try to catch them on their tongues. The ingenue, landing one on her hot cheek, dissolves into a fit of laughter. In Fishtown a nightmare trebles through the nose and paws of a dog snoozing under construction flats. The stone deity that rules the Rittenhouse Square fountain switches to life with a pronouncement of water while Curtis Hall musicians, late for final rehearsal, arpeggiate through the park. The flurries somersault, reconsider, double back. The alleys of 9th Street bear witness as they softly change their minds.
Blurbworthiness: "2 a.m. at the Cat's Pajamas is as winning and funny as the nine year-old at its heart, and I love it for the way its protagonists turn their back on their city’s cruddiness and their own losses to proclaim their happiness to be in this world. They offer wryness as the antidote to self-pity and benevolence as the antidote to isolation, and they demonstrate how even the most forsaken can turn themselves into a warm, dry house."  (Jim Shepard, author of Like You’d Understand, Anyway)


The Secret of Raven Point by Jennifer Vanderbes (Scribner):  As with so many books, my initial attention was snagged by the striking cover design of Jennifer Vanderbes' new novel, The Secret of Raven Point.  Half a profile and one eye of a World War Two-era WAC can be seen behind a sheet of yellowed, stained and torn memo paper which bears the book's title and a small red cross (nicely linked to the girl's bright red lipstick as well as her job as an Army nurse).  Man, I can't stop staring at this cover.  But eventually I have to, of course, and I step into the pages.  The cover may have caught my eye, but it will be the words inside which will no doubt keep me there.  Vanderbes (who also wrote the highly-acclaimed novels Easter Island and Strangers at the Feast) opens her newest book with this vivid prologue:
      The German puts his hands behind his head, biting at his lower lip, and gets down on his knees. He's looking at the ground, and his helmet tilts forward over his eyes, but he's too scared to move it. "Nicht Schießen," he says. "Nicht Schießen." He keeps repeating that in these short, stabbing whispers, like he's talking to himself, talking to God. Sergeant McKnight's watching him, kicking at the dirt, that vein in his forehead getting fat. He orders Rakowski and Dufresne to take the Jerry to the rear, so they each grab an elbow and haul the German off the ground and start heading back toward the wall....
      McKnight's looking at me. "Stop batting your fucking eyelashes at every Jerry," he says. Just as Rakowski and Dufresne get close to the wall, McKnight signals them to let go of the sniper. So the German's standing there all alone, his helmet still tilted, and McKnight trains his rifle on him. McKnight's just waiting, waiting for him to start moving, and finally the Jerry takes one step, then another, and soon he's walking, walking faster, staring at the ground, breaking into a run, and I hear a gun go pop.
When Vanderbes first mentions that fat vein on McKnight's forehead, we just know there's going to be trouble.  I also love the movement in that last sentence—linguistically and literally—which starts off at a walk, then breaks into a run, hurrying toward the finality of the pop just before the period.  If the remainder of the book is this good, then we're all in for a treat.  But what is the rest of the novel about, you ask?  Here's the Jacket Copy to explain:
1943: When seventeen-year-old Juliet Dufresne receives a cryptic letter from her enlisted older brother pleading for help, and then finds out he’s been reported missing overseas, she lies about her age and volunteers as an army nurse to find him. Shy and awkward, Juliet is thrust into the bloody chaos of a field hospital, living in a sprawling encampment north of Rome where she forges new friendships with her fellow nurses and is increasingly consumed by the plight of her patients. One in particular, Christopher Barnaby, a deserter awaiting court martial, may hold the answer to her brother’s fate—but the trauma of war has left him unable to speak. Racing against the clock, Juliet works with an enigmatic young psychiatrist, Henry Willard, to heal Barnaby’s psychic wound before the authorities take him away and any clues as to her brother’s fate are forever lost. Plunged into the horrifying depths of one man’s combat memories, Juliet and Willard are forced to plumb the moral nuances of a so-called just war, and to face the dangers of their own deepening connection. Reminiscent of Pat Barker’s Regeneration, The Secret of Raven Point is a war saga capturing the experiences of soldiers after the battles have ended. And as few novels have done, it depicts the ravages of war through the eyes of a young woman.
I can't be certain, but I think the person narrating the prologue might be the shell-shocked Barnaby; and, unless I'm further mistaken, Vanderbes is hinting that he's gay ("Stop batting your fucking eyelashes at every Jerry"). If so, this is setting up a nice tension for an already-promising narrative.

Friday, December 13, 2013

Friday Freebie: American Dream Machine by Matthew Specktor and The Flamethrowers by Rachel Kushner


Congratulations to Michael Cooper, winner of last week's Friday Freebie: N0S4A2 by Joe Hill.

This week's book giveaway is another double-book delight: American Dream Machine by Matthew Specktor and The Flamethrowers by Rachel Kushner.  Both of these novels have been popping up on year-end "Best Of" lists and while I haven't had the chance to read them, I'm pretty sure they'd be among my top reading choices of the year.  One lucky reader will win hardcover editions of both books (Bonus!  American Dream Machine comes with a special brochure provided by publisher Tin House Books—a map and guide to the Hollywood locations in the novel).


I absolutely loved the opening paragraph of American Dream Machine:
They closed down the Hamlet on Sunset last night. That old plush palace, place where Dean Martin drank himself to death on Tuesdays, where my father and his friends once had lunch every weekend and the maître d’ was quick to kiss my old man’s hand. Like the one they called “the other Hamlet” in Beverly Hills, and “the regular other Hamlet” in Century City . . . all of these places now long gone. Hollywood is like that. Its forever institutions, so quick to disappear. The Hamburger Hamlet, the one on Sunset, was in a class by itself. Red leather upholstery, dark booths, the carpets patterned with a radical and problematic intaglio. Big windows flung sun in front, but farther in the interior was dim, swampy. Waitresses patrolled the tables, the recessed depths where my father’s clients, men like Stacy Keach and Arthur Hill, sat away from human scrutiny. Most often their hair was mussed and they were weeping. Or they were exultant, flashing lavish smiles and gold watches, their bands’ mesh grain muted by the ruinous lighting, those overhead bulbs that shone down just far enough to make the waitresses’ faces look like they were melting under heat lamps. And yet the things that were consummated there: divorces, deals! I saw George Clooney puking in one of the ficuses back by the men’s room, one time when I was in.
Here's more about the book from the publisher: "American Dream Machine is the story of two talent agents and their three troubled boys, heirs to Hollywood royalty. It’s a sweeping narrative about fathers and sons, the movie business, and the sundry sea changes that have shaped Hollywood and, by extension, American life. Beau Rosenwald—overweight, not particularly handsome, and improbably charismatic—arrives in Los Angeles in 1962 with nothing but an ill-fitting suit and a pair of expensive brogues. By the late 1970s he has helped found the most successful agency in Hollywood. Through the eyes of his son, we watch Beau and his partner go to war, waging a seismic battle that redraws the lines of an entire industry. We watch Beau rise and fall and rise again, in accordance with the cultural transformations that dictate the fickle world of movies. We watch Beau's partner, the enigmatic and cerebral Williams Farquarsen, struggle to contain himself, to control his impulses and consolidate his power. And we watch two generations of men fumble and thrive across the LA landscape, learning for themselves the shadows and costs exacted by success and failure. Mammalian, funny, and filled with characters both vital and profound, American Dream Machine is a piercing interrogation of the role—nourishing, as well as destructive—that illusion plays in all our lives."


The Flamethrowers burst on the scene with a loud confetti cannon earlier this year.  It seems like everyone loved Rachel Kushner's novel—including JFranz:
“I loved Rachel Kushner’s The Flamethrowers.”  (Jonathan Franzen)

“Rachel Kushner’s fearless, blazing prose ignites the 70s New York art scene and Italian underground of The Flamethrowers.”  (Elissa Schappell)

The Flamethrowers unfolds on a bigger, brighter screen than nearly any recent American novel I can remember. It plays out as if on IMAX, or simply higher-grade film stock.”  (Dwight Garner)

“Life, gazed at with exemplary intensity over hundreds of pages and thousands of sentences precision-etched with detail—that’s what The Flamethrowers feels like. That’s what it is. And it could scarcely be better. The Flamethrowers is a political novel, a feminist novel, a sexy novel, and a kind of thriller…Virtually every page contains a paragraph that merits—and rewards—rereading."  (Tom Bissell)

“Rachel Kushner’s new novel, The Flamethrowers, is a high-wire performance worthy of Philippe Petit. On lines stretched tight between satire and eulogy, she strolls above the self-absorbed terrain of the New York art scene in the 1970s, providing a vision alternately intimate and elevated…[Kushner is] a superb recent-historical novelist…20 brilliant pages [of The Flamethrowers] could make any writer’s career: a set piece of New York night life that’s a daze of comedy, poignancy and violence…What really dazzles…is her ability to steer this zigzag plot so expertly that she can let it spin out of control now and then…The Flamethrowers concludes with two astonishing scenes: one all black, one all white, as striking as any of the desert photographs Reno aspires to shoot, but infinitely richer and more evocative. Hang on: This is a trip you don’t want to miss.”  (Ron Charles)
Okay, but what's it about?  I'm glad you asked, sailor.  Here's the publisher's synopsis, nutshell-style:
The year is 1975 and Reno—so-called because of the place of her birth—has come to New York intent on turning her fascination with motorcycles and speed into art. Her arrival coincides with an explosion of activity in the art world—artists have colonized a deserted and industrial SoHo, are staging actions in the East Village, and are blurring the line between life and art. Reno meets a group of dreamers and raconteurs who submit her to a sentimental education of sorts. Ardent, vulnerable, and bold, she begins an affair with an artist named Sandro Valera, the semi-estranged scion of an Italian tire and motorcycle empire. When they visit Sandro’s family home in Italy, Reno falls in with members of the radical movement that overtook Italy in the seventies. Betrayal sends her reeling into a clandestine undertow.
If you’d like a chance at winning both American Dream Machine and The Flamethrowers, simply email your name and mailing address to

Put FRIDAY FREEBIE in the e-mail subject line.  One entry per person, please.  Despite its name, the Friday Freebie runs all week long and remains open to entries until midnight on Dec. 19, at which time I’ll draw the winning name.  I’ll announce the lucky reader on Dec. 20.  If you’d like to join the mailing list for the once-a-week newsletter, simply add the words “Sign me up for the newsletter” in the body of your email.  Your email address and other personal information will never be sold or given to a third party (except in those instances where the publisher requires a mailing address for sending Friday Freebie winners copies of the book).

Want to double your odds of winning?  Get an extra entry in the contest by posting a link to this webpage on your blog, your Facebook wall or by tweeting it on Twitter.  Once you’ve done any of those things, send me an additional e-mail saying “I’ve shared” and I’ll put your name in the hat twice.


Thursday, December 12, 2013

Stories Within Stories: S. by Doug Dorst and J. J. Abrams


S.
by Doug Dorst and J. J. Abrams
Review by James Bennett

I am a book guy, for lack of a better term. When I bought my new house, the first major project I started on was remodeling the basement, with built in bookshelves on which to stack my collected tomes. I have nothing against e-readers, in fact I own both a Nook and a Kindle (I prefer the Kindle Fire, quite a useful device) but still when I decided to take the leap and read Ulysses I went with an old hardback version (a U.S. first edition I proudly managed to pick up at a used book store for the paltry price of $7) even at the risk of damaging it, rather than simply reading it off the screen.

So I suppose it should not come as a surprise that I would be fascinated by a book that I had come across at the local Barnes and Noble, not for its content, in fact I was completely unfamiliar with the author (although not the creator, more on that later) or the subject of the book, but by its physical appearance.

There it was, lying on the table in a cardboard sleeve and shrinkwrapped, the story S., created by noted film and television director J. J. Abrams, and written by relative unknown college professor Doug Dorst. I could make out the format of the book based on the description and what I could see of this spine, but it was not until I got it home and ripped off the plastic with my greedy little hands, that I truly saw what I was in for.

S. is the story (as opposed to the actual novel) of a mysterious character and amnesiac who knows himself only by that initial, and the mysterious stylized letter that keeps on popping up everywhere. What S. consists of though, is much more complicated, but that is not the book itself. The book itself is in the form of an old library book, published in 1949, titled Ship of Theseus, written by the entirely fictional enigmatic author V. M. Straka, a world renowned literary legend and contemporary of Ernest Hemingway and F. Scott Fitzgerald.

OK, following along? Now the story, as opposed to the novel, is that of Straka, which is taken to the second level by the translator F. X. Caldeira, who uses the foreword and the footnotes to communicate to both the original author, and the reader, both overtly and through codes and clues scattered throughout the text. But wait, we aren’t done yet! The story, once again as opposed to the novel, begins not with the text of the novel, or the comments of the translator, but with a handwritten note scribbled in the margins in blue pen:
      Hey–I found your stuff while I was shelving. (Looks like you left in a hurry!) I read a few chapters & loved it. Felt bad about keeping the book from you, though since you obviously need it for your work.
      Have to get my own copy!
         –Jen
Jen, who we soon find out is an English student at the fictional Pollard State University, then begins communicating with the original owner of the book, a grad student named Eric. The book itself, an aged yellowed and stained library book, complete with stamps bearing the checkout dates of previous patrons, was swiped by Eric from his high school library. It becomes the medium for the story, not the story itself.


Eric and Jen communicate their personal stories and develop a relationship as they analyze the book Ship of Theseus to discover more about what the identity of the great literary legend V. M. Straka. As a result, this work ends up existing on several different levels, not just as a book, but a tribute to books itself. The book not only contains the story, it is part of the story itself. It is the book as theater, and its pages are the stage upon which the play is presented.

Based on what I have said, it should come as no surprise that I enjoyed it immensely, although by its very nature it is an extremely complicated read without a clear ending. At some point I am going to have to go back through it and reread it to see what I missed. I think much of this is intentional, as the story exists in much more than just the text of the novel, but in the actions of Jen and Eric and the backstory of the author itself. Another clue to this is that the publisher has also provided other resources to follow the story, chief among them two websites eotvoswheel.com and radiostraka.com which provide even more information about Straka. Fan-generated sites have already been created to discuss the secrets of the book and share insights and discoveries.

The theme of the novel, which is even hinted to in its title Ship of Theseus, is that of the nature of identity, which is of course also the subject of the wider narrative as to the identity of Straka. An even more intriguing point it raised though, is what is the nature of literature? What defines a great work of literature and what quality makes up a classic?

As I mentioned earlier, the original concept for this story was created by J. J. Abrams who apparently being too busy making Star Trek and Star Wars movies had his production company Bad Robot search for an author to bring his concept to life. They found Doug Dorst, a writing teacher at Texas State University–San Marcos, known mostly for a comedic ghost story called Alive in Necropolis. Now Dorst seems like a reasonably talented writer, although I have not read his previous work, but Abrams obviously had a rather difficult challenge in front of him in casting his author.

A quick aside: I am a big fan of the HBO show Entourage, a series about a movie star named Vincent Chase and his childhood friends who make up the show’s title. A few years ago I watched one of those “making of” specials where they discussed the difficulties they had casting the young stars in the show (the only really established actor being the super agent Ari Gold, played by Jeremy Piven). The main problem being, who do you cast to realistically play a movie star, who isn’t already a movie star? The show’s producers ended up going with the completely unknown Adrian Grenier, an actor with movie star looks, if limited acting ability, which is indicated by the fact that despite the popularity of this award winning show, he has appeared in little else.

So Abrams was left with a similar dilemma: how do you have someone pull off writing a classic novel written by a literary genius, without having a classic literary genius to write it in the first place? This also brings us to the more basic question: what defines a classic work of literature in the first place?

This is a subject I can hardly answer in one short essay, and this review is getting too long to begin with, but I would argue that it would consist of three things:

1.  The use of prose in a sophisticated and stylistic manner.
2.  Thematic depth which goes beyond just the storyline.
3.  A book which is appreciated over time and not just by one generation.

The collaborators of this works certainly can’t directly address the third point, since they won’t know the lasting effect of this book for quite some time. As enjoyable as I thought it was, it may just be a flash in the pan, all but forgotten in a few years and relegated to the clearance bins of history. The first two points are where they seemed to have focused their effort.

First of all, the style: Dorst uses flowery, period-specific vocabulary and almost Kafkaesque imagery. For example from the text on page 274:
He is swimming in a mountain lake, and she is waiting for him on the far bank. They are at high elevation: the flora consists solely of twisted krumm-holz formations, and the moon, fat and gold, takes up an eighth of the night sky. He strokes and kicks through ink-dark water but gets no closer to her. She waves, calls out something that might be his name, and he strokes faster, kicks harder, but gets no closer--he might even be drifting backward--and this is when he feels tiny punctures breaking the skin of his belly, thighs, feet and legs as leeches begin feeding on him, and the dread that grips him has nothing to do with losing blood or realizing he has become some other creature’s prey but rather has to do with fear of what he will look like to her when he gets out of the water, and he wonders whether perhaps it isn’t better to drown.
The second point, the use of multiple layers of meaning, I have already addressed, which of course exist in this story even one layer deeper through the further story of the author and Jen and Eric. So does the author create the illusion of a classic work of literature through this? This is entirely subjective of course, but I would argue yes. Like any book, it has its weak points--some strained metaphors and awkwardly-worded passages--but it at least gives the impression of a novel which could have been considered a classic at some point in time.


This doesn’t necessarily mean that what we perceive as “literary classics” are the most successful novels, but that they fit into a certain perceived class, as opposed to the controversial taxonomy of what is often referred to as “genre fiction.” One can certainly have an incredibly popular and well-received novel and not have it considered literary. Consider the works of John LeCarre and Tom Clancy. They both wrote spy thrillers, but the former is considered literary, while even rabid Clancy fans would not consider him a writer of literary fiction, even though as far as thriller writers go he was arguably much more successful.

This is of course an argument with no true boundaries or solutions, but that is what I found most intriguing about this work. S. is a tribute to the book, in its physical form, worn and tattered pages yellowed and smelling faintly of mold and mildew, and it is also a tribute to the written word in general, great writers in all of their eccentricities, and the never-ending question of what great art truly is. As such, it succeeds in existing beyond mere printed words on a page.


James Bennett is a retired National Guard Chief Warrant Officer, who currently masquerades as a software engineer in Seattle, while reading and writing on the side. He's the author of two (unpublished) novels: The Team and The Interrogator. A version of this review originally appeared at The Chief Brief blog.