These Living Songs: Reading Montana Poetry wrote about Big Sky poetry legends like Richard Hugo, James Welch, Lowell Jaeger, Melissa Kwasny, Roger Dunsmore and Tami Haaland, I chose a big bear of a man whose hands were once creased black with dirt and whose poems had the lung-rattle of silica dust: Butte native Ed Lahey.
“Ed who?” many of you are asking--even those of you who are well-versed in Montana verse. Don't worry, I myself hadn't heard of Lahey before I moved to the Mining City in early 2009 (and even then, he was hardly a household name here in Butte). It was only after his death two years later that I cracked open his collected poem, Birds of a Feather, and realized that if he wasn't well-known, then by God, I'd try to do something about that, in my own small way.
That's why I was thrilled to be asked by editors Lisa Simon and Brady Harrison to come up with something for this new anthology, now out from University of Montana Press. Here's an excerpt from what I wrote:
I stand at the edge of the Alice Pit, a dry, abandoned hole in the hill above Butte. Someone with high hopes once dug here, the first open pit mine in Butte. Someone with mineral lust once scooped away the soil, ears ringing with the bells of a thousand cash registers. The Alice only lasted five years before shutting down, the failed dreams blowing away in the wind that knifes its way from Walkerville down to Butte. Now it’s been reclaimed, a bowl of green, terraced like the seats in a football stadium.
I linger at the lip of the hole on a late April day. The wind at my back wants to push me into the pit, tumble me down the green scar of earth.
I’ve come here as a sort of personal eulogy to Butte’s unofficial poet laureate who, I just learned, has died in an assisted-living home up in Missoula. Staring at a hole in the ground seems a fitting tribute to Ed Lahey. His, after all, was the voice of the miner—one in a long tradition of writers in Montana who made mining central to their work. Men like novelist Myron Brinig who described Butte as “a gaudy scramble of races and creeds” in his autobiographical novel Singermann, published in 1919. In “The Idealist,” published in The Last Best Place: A Montana Anthology, Butte poet Berton Braley unapologetically defends his mining town against its detractors:
Ugly and bleak? Well, maybe,Lahey also scratched beneath the copper-rich surface of Butte, but what he found was less beautiful than Braley’s greeting-card vision.
But my eyes have learned to find
The beauty of truth, not substance,
The beauty that lies behind.
Lahey’s poem “The Beauty and the Beast,” from his 2005 collection, Birds of a Feather, growls in my ear as I stare at the Alice: “empty as a starling’s song . . . / a small acidic lake / above the wounded town.” Lahey was keenly attuned to the sensitivity of Butte. Despite their reputation for living in a rough-and-tumble town, residents of the Mining City rarely stop thinking about these lakes of poison, poised to tip and spill across the already-wounded town (fittingly renamed “Poisonville” by Dashiell Hammett in his 1929 private-eye novel Red Harvest). Those lines from “The Beauty and the Beast” serve as both lament and warning.
Lahey was an artist who found commonplace beauty in the wreckage of a town like Butte. Read his poems closely and you’ll discover a man torn between celebrating the town’s decadent past and wryly, ruefully mourning what it has become.
Look, for instance, at one of his most celebrated poems, “The Ballad of the Board of Trade Bar.” The bar is gone now—a parking lot next to the old city hall marks its place like a missing tooth in a mouth that used to smile—but for the space of Lahey’s poem, it comes alive again with the kind of verbal energy typical of his other work.
“The Ballad of the Board of Trade Bar” centers around a prostitute named Coal Oil Belle who “was a red lamp legend / in a brown town.” Each night as the shift-change whistle echoed around town (aurally illustrated in Lahey’s internal rhyme), Belle could be found “behind a smelter stack,” plying her trade.
Belle is literally a colorful figure in Lahey’s “brown town”; the color red is mentioned twice and then there’s the silver-lined coffin in which she’s buried. In his poem, Lahey buries her “beneath a smoking torch”—which could refer to the lovelorn torch her customers still carry for her, but more tellingly points to the smoldering smelter stacks of the dozens of mines dotting Butte’s landscape. “In a town of misery,” Lahey writes, “one needs sentimental history.”
He saves his most bitter sentiment for the final stanza where Belle gets the last laugh. There she is in her silver coffin, “ten pounds of bone” residing in the mineral-rich earth for which Butte was known. “[W]hen the whistles blow,” Lahey supposes, “her earless sockets listen” and her hips still move in sexual rhythm “to the pocket sound / of a lover’s jingle.” It’s a marvelous marriage of earthy sexuality and criticism of the crass materialism (silver coins jingling in a pocket) that was rampant in Butte.
Lahey had an unmistakable love/hate relationship with his hometown. It is, as he writes in “Deep Bells,” a “city of tired miners.” It is also a city of “mystic mountains, blue sky, that / furls around the town, still as hesitant air.” Butte is ugly, Butte is beautiful, and it works its way into your soul like coal dust into the seams of your palms. It is a stoic place, “a place of private / struggle.”
I once heard someone say, “When I listened to him read, it was like hearing the resonance of the earth.” And yet, he never rose as large as he should have on Montana’s literary map.
After Lahey died on April 27, 2011—two days before I walked to the edge of the Alice Pit—it took more than a week for his obituary to appear in the local Butte newspaper, and even then his passing didn’t so much as raise a ripple on the toxic waters of the city’s Berkeley Pit (“twenty billion gallons and rising,” he writes in his poem “A Note From the Third World”). Lahey, the son of a miner and a former worker in Butte’s Swiss-cheese network of mines, struggled for popular recognition during his life and, it seems, even after death.
By contrast, there was a much louder and more public mourning two hours up the interstate in Missoula where some of Lahey’s closest friends— mostly writers and artists—reeled in shock and sadness at news of his death. He’d been ill for quite some time—a broken man at the end of what even he called a heartbreak life—but still it was hard to believe he was gone.
“He had the most beautiful and large soul and it spilled over into our lives,” said Sheryl Noethe, then Montana’s poet laureate.
Lahey wrote raw-nerve poems of blue-collar life, but his work went largely unchampioned by that very laboring class. He often stands in the shadow of his contemporary and mentor, Richard Hugo, but the two poets share similar themes in the concentration of their work: the dim drink-stained bar, the bruised knuckles from a fistfight, the comfort of a prostitute’s bed.
Lahey’s poem “In My Three Act Dream” describes how comfort is sought in drink (“good corn bourbon / smoking my liver”) and women (“my green-eyed girl with the apple breasts”). In Lahey’s Butte, prostitutes like Coal Oil Belle earn their wages behind smelter stacks, offering themselves under the neon blaze of Butte’s uptown district, debasing themselves for underground men, but when the end comes they’re buried in $2,000 engraved coffins lined with silver.
“The town has grown into my nervous system,” Lahey told a reporter in 2005. “Sometimes I feel like a hostage in a war, but I am glad, too.” The wind at the Alice Pit stabs me in the back and I head down off the hill to my house on the Flats where I open the paper (the Missoula paper) and read Lahey’s obituary in that day’s edition.
MISSOULA – Edward Thomas Lahey was born in Butte on July 8, 1936, to Edward and Frances Lahey, and grew up in a successful and colorful mining family, the youngest of two. He died on Wednesday, April 27, 2011, in Missoula....After achieving a Master of Arts in English from the University of Montana, Ed went on to teach American literature (and was a member of Richard Hugo’s poetry workshop). He left teaching in the late 1960s, and devoted the remainder of his life to his work. His first book of poetry, The Blind Horses, won the first Montana Arts Council First Book Award in 1979. Clark City Press published a complete collection of Ed’s poetry, Birds of a Feather in 2005. In 2008, he received the Montana Arts Council Governor’s Arts award for his lifetime work. Later in 2008, his semi-fictional memoir, The Thin Air Gang was published.
Mines are merciless and so were the mining companies who poisoned the Richest Hill on Earth while also lining their corporate pockets with copper. Lahey burned with anger at the way Butte workers were treated and that boiled over into his stanzas. In one of my favorite poems, “A Different Price,” he writes:
Topside,The mine doesn’t care. It has callous disregard for its workers. They are meat in its machine. Lahey knew this, he lived it, and he wrote sympathetically of those who were caught in the cogs—both literal and metaphoric. As his poem “In My Three Act Dream” tells us, “payday’s just a shack / at the edge of the great pit’s lip.”
a bull gear caught Haggerty’s hand,
slick iron on a wet day.
I heard him speak to it.
“Whoa,” he said.
It cut his hand off anyway.
Postscript: Lahey's good friend, fellow poet Mark Gibbons, writes movingly of a visit he paid to E. L. in his last days in a nursing home. Take a look at “The King of Poetry” on Gibbons' website--then be sure to check out his other books of poetry, including Forgotten Dreams and Shadowboxing.